Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, or EMDR, is one of the better-known approaches in trauma therapy. With that visibility have come a number of myths. They come from headlines, from stories that travelled further than the facts, and from an understandable wish that healing could be simple and fast. This post is a plain-language look at those misconceptions. It is not a substitute for a conversation with a qualified clinician, and it does not promise a particular outcome.
At Clinique Altera, we offer EMDR as one part of trauma-informed care, in person at our Rosemont, Montréal office and online across Québec and Ontario. We also offer related body-based approaches, including Brainspotting and other somatic therapies, when they are a good fit.
What EMDR actually is
EMDR is a structured form of psychotherapy. It was developed to help people process distressing memories that still feel “stuck”: memories that can arrive as vivid images, body sensations, intense emotions, or sharp negative beliefs about yourself.
You and your therapist first spend time on history, safety, and preparation. When it is appropriate to begin processing, you briefly focus on a target memory while also following a form of bilateral stimulation, often guided eye movements, and sometimes tapping or tones. The aim is not to wipe the memory away. It is to help the nervous system digest what was overwhelming at the time, so the memory can be remembered with less charge. The American Psychological Association describes this process in its overview of EMDR Therapy.
Myth 1: “EMDR is hypnosis.”
EMDR is not hypnosis. You are not put into a trance, and you are not asked to hand over control of your mind to someone else. In a typical session, you remain awake, aware, and in conversation with your therapist. You can pause, slow down, or stop. If you have had a difficult experience with feeling out of control, it is reasonable to ask how your therapist paces the work, and what you can say if something starts to feel like too much.
Myth 2: “EMDR erases memories.”
EMDR does not erase what happened. People sometimes hope it will; others fear it will, as if a part of their life might disappear. A more accurate way to think about it is this: the event still happened, and you still know that it happened. What can change, over time and with careful work, is how the memory lives in your body and your present-day life. No responsible clinician can promise that a memory will fade, or that a certain number of sessions will “clear” an experience. The hope is not amnesia. It is more room to live in the present.
Myth 3: “EMDR is only for PTSD, or only for veterans.”
EMDR was first developed as a treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and much of the formal research still focuses there. PTSD, though, is not limited to combat, and trauma is not limited to a single dramatic event. People seek this work after accidents, medical experiences, assault, childhood adversity, grief, relationship injuries, and the accumulated stress of work that exposes them to other people’s trauma.
At Clinique Altera, our EMDR and Brainspotting page describes a range of concerns that clients bring to this kind of therapy. The strongest guideline support is for PTSD. That does not mean EMDR is only for people with a formal PTSD diagnosis, and it does not mean it is the right tool for every difficulty.
Myth 4: “EMDR is a quick fix. One session should do it.”
Some people do notice a shift in how a particular memory feels after a relatively short period of processing. The APA notes that processing of a specific memory is generally completed within one to three sessions, and that EMDR is typically delivered once or twice a week, often over a total of about 6 to 12 sessions, though some people need fewer and some need more. That is a description of a common treatment structure, not a guarantee. Preparation also takes time. Before reprocessing begins, a therapist needs to understand your history, help you build ways to stay grounded, and assess whether now is the right moment for this work. A promise that EMDR will resolve trauma in a single appointment is not consistent with how the therapy is designed, or with ethical practice.
Myth 5: “You have to retell everything in detail.”
Many people delay trauma therapy because they cannot bear the idea of narrating every moment of what happened, in order, to a stranger. EMDR is structured differently from therapies that rely on repeated, detailed retelling. The APA notes that EMDR does not include extended exposure to the distressing memory or detailed descriptions of the trauma in the way some other treatments do. At Clinique Altera, we also describe both EMDR and Brainspotting as approaches that can support reprocessing without requiring you to repeatedly recount painful experiences in detail. You will still need to share enough for your therapist to understand what you are working on and to keep the work safe. You do not have to perform the story.
Myth 6: “The eye movements are the whole thing.”
The eye movements are the part of EMDR that people remember, because they look unusual. They are not the whole therapy. EMDR is an eight-phase approach that includes history-taking, preparation, assessment of a target memory, processing, and later evaluation of how the work is holding. Bilateral stimulation (eye movements, and sometimes tapping or tones) is one element of that process. A good clinician will explain the structure, use stimulation in a way that fits you, and keep the relationship, pacing, and safety at the centre of the work. The movements are a tool, not a magic trick.
Myth 7: “EMDR is just a technique you add on to your regular therapy.”
EMDR can be done alongside other therapy, and sometimes that is a good fit. It is not, though, a quick add-on or a tool to drop into another approach for a session or two. EMDR is a complete psychotherapy in its own right, with its own structure, phases, and pacing. The first few phases, history-taking and preparation, are not a formality. For many people, especially those with complex or long-standing trauma, this part of the work takes real time. It is where you and your therapist build safety, stability, and trust, and where you develop ways to stay grounded before any memory processing begins. If you are already working with another therapist, it is worth talking openly with both clinicians about how the two pieces of work will fit together.
Myth 8: “EMDR isn’t evidence-based.”
EMDR is not an untested internet trend. It is a recognized psychological treatment for PTSD, with a place in major clinical guidelines.
The World Health Organization’s fact sheet on post-traumatic stress disorder states that the psychological interventions with the most evidence for effective treatment of PTSD are trauma-focused cognitive behavioural therapy and EMDR. In its mhGAP guidance, updated in 2023, WHO includes EMDR among the interventions that should be considered for adults with PTSD (a conditional recommendation) and among those that should be offered for children and adolescents with PTSD (a strong recommendation). See the adult guidance.
The American Psychological Association’s Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of PTSD in Adults suggests EMDR as a treatment for PTSD. This is a conditional, sometimes described as second-line, recommendation, which APA explains in What is EMDR therapy and why is it used to treat PTSD?. The evidence is real. It is strongest for PTSD. And the right treatment for you still depends on your history, your preferences, and a conversation with a qualified clinician.
A word about safety
Trauma therapy can stir up difficult feelings, even when it is paced carefully. If you are in immediate danger, or thinking of harming yourself or someone else, call 911. In Canada, you can also contact the 988 Suicide Crisis Helpline by call or text, 24 hours a day.
If you are curious about next steps
At Clinique Altera, EMDR is offered within a wider, trauma-informed approach. Our clinicians may integrate it with Brainspotting and other somatic, body-based therapies when that is a good fit. Services are available in person in Rosemont, Montréal, and online across Québec and Ontario.
If you have questions, you are welcome to book a free 15-minute consultation call, or to read more about EMDR, Brainspotting, and somatic therapies. A short call is simply a chance to ask questions and see whether a first session would make sense. There is no obligation to continue.
Clinique Altera offers trauma-informed psychotherapy in person at 2520 Beaubien Est, Suite 300, Montréal, QC H1Y 1G2, and online across Québec and Ontario. Phone: (438) 944-6432. Email: info@clinicaltera.com.

